Home › News & Events › Impact Story: Supporting strat…

News

Impact Story: Supporting strategic development: Early and ongoing Design Review in Swansea

How more than two decades of collaboration between DCFW and Swansea Council, alongside its regeneration partner Urban Splash, demonstrate the value of early and ongoing Design Review in shaping ambitious places.

The project

Major regeneration projects are shaped by decisions made long before a planning application is submitted. Choices around vision, layout, movement, character, sustainability and delivery can have a lasting influence on the quality of the places being created.

Since its establishment in 2002, DCFW has consistently advocated for independent design input at these early stages, when there is the greatest opportunity to influence a project’s direction.

Swansea Council has used DCFW’s Design Review service for more than two decades as part of its commitment to positive placemaking. The relationship spans projects of different types and scales, from individual homes in sensitive locations to strategic housing, heritage regeneration, regeneration strategies and priority city centre developments.

This approach has now extended to Urban Splash, Swansea Council’s long-term regeneration partner.

Formed in 2022, the 20-year partnership includes sites connected to the City on the Beach Vision. Its ambition is to create a visitor destination that also serves Swansea’s communities.

Achieving this requires more than the design of individual buildings. It means considering how developments connect with the wider city, how people experience them and how different parts of the proposals work together to create successful places.

Swansea Council and Urban Splash engaged DCFW while ideas were still evolving, creating an opportunity to explore the emerging proposals before key decisions became fixed.

Our approach

Through Design Review, DCFW brings together an independent multidisciplinary panel to provide constructive challenge and informed professional perspectives.

The process is not about telling project teams what to do or providing a single approved answer. Instead, it creates a space for open discussion, allowing teams to explain their thinking, test assumptions, explore alternatives and consider perspectives that might otherwise be overlooked.

For Urban Splash, engaging at such an early stage initially felt uncertain. However, the experience gave the team greater confidence in its core proposition and encouraged it to be even bolder.

Following the initial review, Urban Splash returned three months later, allowing the conversation to continue as the proposals developed.

Swansea Design Review Site Visit

The value of early engagement

“We have seen great value in early and ongoing design review engagement.”

– David Warburton, Development Director, Urban Splash

This continuing relationship demonstrates how Design Review can support the development process over time, rather than providing a one-off assessment of a finished proposal.

Early conversations can help shape objectives and establish direction. Subsequent reviews provide opportunities to assess how proposals have evolved, identify new opportunities and maintain a coherent vision.

Swansea Council actively encourages projects to use DCFW’s service before submitting a planning application. Its experience is that the process creates positive and collaborative conversations that help improve both individual proposals and the wider placemaking culture of project teams.

A collaborative process

“This is always positive and collaborative conversation, and projects are always improved by this process.”

– Steve Smith, Placemaking and Heritage Lead, Swansea Council

The difference it made

One of the most important benefits of early Design Review is the opportunity to identify challenges and opportunities while there is still flexibility to respond.

When a project is presented only once it feels complete, teams may have less scope to make changes and can become more invested in proposals that have already required considerable time and resources.

Early engagement creates room to explore different approaches, challenge assumptions and strengthen the overall ambition before decisions become more difficult or costly to change.

For Urban Splash, independent design advice provided reassurance to pursue a more ambitious approach. Rather than prescribing a particular design direction, the panel encouraged the team to push its ideas further.

Encouraging greater ambition

“Rather than prescriptive design direction, we received encouragement to be even bolder – a tacit endorsement that gave us confidence to push boundaries.”

– David Warburton, Development Director, Urban Splash

The process also provided an independent point of reference for both the developer and the local authority.

For developers, constructive challenge can build confidence in ambitious ideas and strengthen the thinking behind proposals. For local authorities, it brings additional professional expertise into discussions and supports a consistent focus on the quality of the places being created.

Importantly, Design Review is a collaborative process, not a regulatory hurdle or a test to pass. It encourages teams to explain their decisions, consider alternatives and make better-informed choices.

The value of timely engagement was also highlighted by Mark Hallett, a DCFW Design Review Panellist and Developer: “Timely Review helps identify opportunities and risks before they become costly problems necessitating change.”

The experience in Swansea has encouraged Urban Splash to commit to engaging DCFW on all major schemes within its partnership with the Council.

This demonstrates the wider potential of making Design Review part of an ongoing strategic relationship, where learning from one project and conversation can inform the next.

Why involve DCFW?

The Swansea experience highlights the importance of early and ongoing independent design advice in shaping strategic developments and major regeneration projects.

It demonstrates how Design Review can help:

  • Shape ambition early: Engage DCFW while the vision and core proposition are still being developed.

  • Support projects over time: Return as proposals evolve, making Design Review an ongoing conversation rather than a one-off exercise.

  • Bring perspectives together: Combine local knowledge, developer experience and independent professional expertise.

  • Encourage better outcomes: Use constructive challenge to strengthen ambition rather than treating review as a test to pass.

  • Build long-term learning: Carry insights across major schemes to support a stronger placemaking culture.

Ultimately, early and ongoing engagement creates more opportunities for teams to make informed decisions, respond to challenges and maintain a clear focus on the quality of the places they are creating.

How DCFW can support your work

DCFW supports local authorities, developers and project teams working on strategic sites and major regeneration proposals.

The earlier we become involved, the greater the opportunity to influence the vision, identify risks and opportunities, and help different partners work towards a shared ambition.

Our free Design Review service is shaped around the needs and stage of each project. We can provide a single review or maintain an ongoing relationship with project teams as proposals develop.

Working on a strategic development or regeneration project? Get in touch to explore how DCFW can support your ambitions.

Contact Us

 

Get the latest news
& events in our newsletter

Sign up to hear more from DCFW.
Subscribe